Skip to content

External editor (Ctrl+G): TUI is not hidden before launching editor, causing screen corruption and lost keystrokes #1092

Open

Description

@PremModhaOfficial

Summary

When Command Code launches an external editor via Ctrl+G, it does not stop/hide its TUI first. The TUI's render loop (git-polling statusline, autocomplete/snippet UI) keeps writing to the terminal and reading stdin while the editor (e.g. nvim) is running. This causes screen corruption and intermittent keystroke loss (Escape, ZZ), so the prompt is sometimes not captured on return.

This is not specific to the kitty keyboard protocol — it reproduces in wezterm, ghostty, alacritty, and kitty.

Reproduction

  1. Run cmd in any of the terminals above.
  2. Type a prompt, press Ctrl+G to open the external editor (nvim).
  3. Type text, idle ~5s, type more, idle ~5s, then ZZ.
  4. Observe: typed text often does not appear in nvim; ZZ may not register; nvim can hang ("Save and close the editor to continue...").

Evidence (cmd vs pi, side-by-side)

Captured in tmux (same terminal, same nvim config). pi calls tui.stop() before spawning the editor and tui.start() after; cmd does not.

Tool nvim opened typing registered survived idle ZZ exited text captured
pi (reference) YES YES YES YES YES
cmd YES NO (buffer stayed empty) n/a NO (stuck) NO

Root cause

In openInEditor (and openMemoryFileInEditor), cmd wraps the spawn in withLegacyKeyboard, which only pops/pushes the kitty keyboard protocol. It never stops the TUI render loop or stdin handling. Contrast pi:

this.tui.stop();
try {
  let result = await editInExternalEditor({ command, content });
  ...
} finally {
  this.tui.start();
  this.tui.requestRender(true);
}

Because cmd's TUI keeps rendering and reading stdin, keystrokes are consumed and the screen is corrupted while nvim is active.

Suggested fix

Mirror pi: before spawning the external editor, stop the TUI (stop rendering + release stdin); after the editor exits, restart the TUI and request a full render. This is the same pattern opencode uses.

nvim-side mitigations already applied (insufficient)

  • Disabled folke/noice.nvim (fixed nvim freeze on exit after idle).
  • ttimeout = true, ttimeoutlen = 0 (helps Escape registration).

These address nvim-specific issues but cannot fix a parent TUI that keeps writing to the terminal / reading stdin. Screen corruption and text-capture loss remain until cmd hides its TUI.

Environment

  • Command Code v1.88.2
  • nvim 0.12.6
  • Reproduced in wezterm, ghostty, alacritty, kitty

Activity

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions

      ⌂ Proxy